Summary ~ Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother: An awe-inspiring, often hilarious, and unerringly honest story of one mother’s exercise in extreme parenting, revealing the rewards-and the costs-of raising her children the Chinese way.
After reading The Glass Castle for my book club’s March selection I felt the intense need to read a book from the opposite end of the parenting spectrum. I found what I needed ten fold in Amy Chua’s memoir, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother. The following quote is what I wrote in my Goodreads.com status update about half way through the book.
| “I’m liking this book so far. Some of it parallels my upbringing and makes me think that not all Western parents are as easy going as she thinks. At least mine weren’t when it came to some things. Piano lessons, practicing, voice lessons, grades and strict parenting were all a way of life in the Brandt house. Though we were “spoiled” on some levels rules were always enforced and fights ensued as in this book.” |
For the most part I related to aspects of daughters Sophia and Lulu as well as Amy and her husband Jed. Amy comes from Chinese immigrant parents (I do not) who raised their daughters with iron fists and did not give in to their Western surroundings and ideas. Amy strived to do the same for her and Jed’s daughters but soon discovered that it wasn’t going to go as smoothly as things seemed to have gone for her parents. (I have to say that I find it curious that a woman who aimed to be the quintessential “Tiger Mother” and raise her daughters in the “Chinese-way” married a white, Jewish American. Just sayin’.)
I did not find myself gasping as I read about the rules, punishments and screaming Amy parented her daughters with. This book came out in late January 2011 and I found it amusing that Amy Chua got so much negative press in the news for her book. I was raised in a strict household and remember many times where I “hated” my parents because they prohibited me from doing what I wanted but in hindsight I was spoiled rotten and the things they did not allow me to do were in my best interest. Due to my observations as a non-parent of parents I think that I probably had it better than those parents children because of the rules upheld in my home that I don’t see followed or even placed in theirs. Now I’m sounding a bit like Amy. Sorry.
I felt that the writing in Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother was good. It wasn’t as narrative as The Glass Castle which read so smoothly and unbelievably that I felt I was reading fiction most of the time. It was however very much a memoir and made me feel like I was watching home movies of this family. The fighting described by Amy to get her youngest and most rebellious daughter to practice her violin were very uncomfortable to read yet brought me back to my youth as a piano student. I took piano lessons for six years starting in first grade. I had a natural ear when it came to singing and the piano and at age four I plucked out the tune of “Follow The Yellow Brick Road”. As soon as I did my mom announced to my dad that she would be starting me in piano lessons in first grade. I did well and progressed quickly but soon it wasn’t fun anymore. I remember my mom yelling from the kitchen, “That’s not your lesson piece! You have to practice your lessons before you can play for fun.” She knew the difference in songs because she sat in the waiting room outside my classroom every week and listened to my teacher instruct me on the pieces I was working on at the time. Mom even went so far as to turn off the grandfather clock in the living room where our piano was so I couldn’t tell who long I had been practicing. I’m pretty sure I only had to practice for thirty minutes a night where Sophia and Lulu practiced three hours a day including weekends and even on vacation but to me those were a long and torturous thirty minutes as the years went on. (Amy would call ahead to the hotels the family would be staying in around the world and request time with the hotel piano for Sophia and they would bring Lulu’s violin with them as carry-on baggage.) Eventually I chose to quit piano in junior high and my parents let me. My sister continued on with her lessons for a few more years and to this day play much better than I do. We both have pianos in our homes now, which I admittedly don’t play much at all but I do turn on the auto-play and enjoy that. It’s a digital upright piano that my parents bought for me. I don’t know how often my sister plays hers but I do know that our parent’s piano continues to be played often by my dad. He loves piano and has always strived to master specific pieces throughout his life. When I was little he had a big black book of classical pieces and as he learned a piece and got fairly good at it he would check it off in the table of contents. There were a lot of checks!
For the most part I didn’t have a problem with Amy’s parenting tactics because of the level of success she and the girls were trying to achieve in piano and violin. I did wish for more peace and quiet for the family as the girls got older though. Like I said, having a peep-hole view of their lives during tumultuous times was uncomfortable. Amy’s writing drew me in and held my attention throughout though and that doesn’t always happen for me in non-fiction/memoirs. I think that from a social study view this is a great book to read if you are a parent or a child of a parent. I think that it will open up discussions in book clubs, on social networks and around the water cooler.
{Rating ~ 4 out of 5}
Below is a pic of my little sister, our Cocker Spaniel Maxwell and me.
Planet Books 
